Families comparing violin teachers often hear two terms: Suzuki lessons and traditional lessons. Violin teacher Barbara Barber, who compared the two in the journal American String Teacher, concluded that they differ mostly in the beginning stages, and more in philosophy than in technique. Here is what that means in practice.
Where the Suzuki method comes from
Shinichi Suzuki (1898 to 1998) was a Japanese violinist who studied music in Germany in the 1920s and began teaching young children in Japan in the 1930s. He saw that children learn their own language with ease, by listening and imitating long before they read, and he applied the same process to music. He called it the Mother Tongue Method, and the whole approach Talent Education.
What Suzuki lessons include
The Suzuki method has these core elements:
- an early start, often at three or four
- lots of listening to music
- learning to play before learning to read
- a parent who takes part in lessons and practice
- a nurturing, positive learning environment
- teachers trained in the method
- a good sound, produced in a balanced and natural way
- a core repertoire that Suzuki students share around the world
- playing with other children
Alongside private lessons, Suzuki students take part in group lessons and performances. At our studio, group classes and recitals are part of the program.
Reading music
Barber put the difference simply: traditional teaching starts with the symbol and then the sound, and Suzuki teaching starts with the sound and then the symbol. In Suzuki teaching, reading traditionally waits until a child's ear and playing are well established, the same way children learn to read words after they can speak. At our studio, we bring reading in from the beginning, alongside the ear.
That does not mean Suzuki students never read. Leaving out music reading was never one of Dr. Suzuki's principles. Barber found that most teachers bring in reading around the second Suzuki book or when a child reaches school age, and that many teach reading from the beginning as a separate skill. We wrote more about this in More Than By Ear: The Suzuki Method and Music Notation.
What traditional lessons usually look like
Traditional teaching is harder to pin down, since it grew out of several hundred years of European teaching handed down from one generation to the next. In Barber's description, traditional teachers:
- usually start students when they are older
- begin with reading, often from method books built on technical exercises
- welcome a parent's support but do not usually ask a parent to take such an active part
- have more freedom to choose each student's pieces
Barber wrote in 1991, and teachers on both sides vary, so read these as tendencies rather than rules.
Which is right for your family?
Neither approach suits every child. A few questions to ask:
- How old is your child? Suzuki teaching is built for children who start before they read.
- Can a parent come to lessons and practice at home during the week?
- Does your child learn well by listening and copying?
- Would your child enjoy group classes and playing alongside other children?
Research has not settled the question yet. A 2024 review found only seven studies that met its standards. Most of them showed that Suzuki teaching helped students' playing, especially their posture, musicality, and technical control, and the authors proposed directions for more research. Seven studies is still a small number.
At our studio, students learn by listening and by reading, through the Suzuki method. To see it for yourself, book a trial lesson or read What is the Suzuki Method?.
Sources
- Traditional and Suzuki teaching compared (opens in a new tab), Barbara Barber, American String Teacher, 1991
- The Suzuki Method (opens in a new tab), International Suzuki Association
- About the Suzuki Method (opens in a new tab), Suzuki Association of the Americas
- About the Suzuki Method (opens in a new tab), Alfred Music, publisher of the Suzuki books
- A review of Suzuki method research (opens in a new tab), Sage Open, 2024
